I’ve decided to change my reviewing approach here

March 31, 2012 § 12 Comments

I’ve given up.  After one too many “tl;dr” comments when I would write 1000-1200 words covering a story’s strengths and deficiencies, I realize that I have to give into that Borg-like mass reviewing system.  So I am going to be implementing a rating system shortly, beginning with my review of Everlast’s upcoming debut novel, Jump Around, later this month.

Since it seems readers do not like it when a reviewer gives a zero star/1 rating, I will also be forced to implement “grade inflation” in order for those tl;dr readers to be better able to correlate my “score” with those of other distinguished reviewers.  Ostensibly, the scale will be based on ten, but in reality, it will go something like this:

6.66  – This work is of the devil.  The prose is wretched, the characterizations pathetic, and there are too many Canadians ruining any possibility of narrative flow.

7.5 – This will be the default rating.  It does not matter if the work is the nth volume of an epic fantasy series that fails to move the plot along or if the novel/collection in question is a brilliant riposte regarding the prejudices shown toward rabid squirrels, unless I get inebriated,stoned, or am betrayed by a rabid squirrel and contract rabies, this shall be the default rating.

8.675309 – The “Jenny” exception, reserved only for novels written by a Jenny or which feature a character named Jenny.

9.0210 – The “Beverly Hills” exception, reserved for novels set in Beverly Hills or which feature a character who thinks that Tori Spelling was a great actress.

Hopefully, these new ratings will help readers to better appreciate the subtle nuances that go into explaining why one novel was mediocre and received a 7.5 while another was brilliant and totally deserved that 7.5 rating.  Does this help clear up any confusion about how well/poorly I rate novels now?


§ 12 Responses to I’ve decided to change my reviewing approach here

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

What’s this?

You are currently reading I’ve decided to change my reviewing approach here at Vaguely Borgesian.


%d bloggers like this: